Alerts & Newsletters

By providing your information, you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy. We use vendors that may also process your information to help provide our services.

When Maison Levanneur, the Centre National de l’Estampe et de l’Art Imprimé, was transformed into an exhibition space for contemporary art, its new director, Sylvie Boulanger, set out to create a program dedicated to recent work that has something to do, at least in part, with printed art, thereby respecting the center’s original mission. Each exhibition is the occasion for the printing of a work or an edition by a contemporary artist.

For “Tatouages” (Tattoos), the recent exhibition by French artist Claude Closky, the walls of the space were covered with various wallpapers. Some of them—Sans titre (cosmétiques) and Sans titre (marabout), both 1997—were already well known, while others, Sans titre (tatouages) and Sans titre (supermarché) were conceived expressly for this show. In the wallpaper that gives the exhibition its title, black curved lines form ornate designs that seem to become endlessly entangled. The supermarché (supermarket) wallpaper, inspired by the visuals of grocery-store ad inserts, features rows of photographed products and their boldly marked prices. By proposing this zero-degree, supermarket aesthetic as a backdrop for our interiors, Closky undermines the semiotics of advertising. The repetition of images from cosmetic ads or promotional offers across a seemingly endless surface dilutes their visual impact and the desire that advertisements are meant to elicit, bringing these representations back to what they truly are (and what the advertisement hopes to mask): namely, signs of objects that are anything but exclusive.

Closky’s iteration of imagery lifted from fashion magazines and cosmetic ads cleverly banalizes their effects, but his work is not limited to this sphere. He has produced a vast assemblage of ballpoint-pen drawings, videos, books, and photographs, some of which were presented in this exhibition, that document both everyday and absurd events and actions. Whether cutting out all the words of a page of a book and arranging them in alphabetical order or making portraits that consist of inscribing on canvas every date of the sitter’s lifetime from his birth up to that point, his project evokes that of On Kawara, with whom Closky seems to share a certain predilection for the inventory of the anodyne behaviors of daily life. Asked about his possible relation to Minimalists and Conceptualists, Closky responds, “The artists that interest me most are those whose practices challenge the function of the work of art to the point of posing the question of its necessity. Today, it seems natural to me to question the necessity of such questioning; to show that in order to respond to these questions, it may be enough not to answer.” While Closky himself eludes all response, he does pose a question to whoever happens on the project he conceived in 1997 for the Dia Center for the Arts’ website: “Do you want love or lust?”—which, like his wallpaper, extends the vacuousness of the rhetoric of women’s magazines to infinity.

Valérie Breuvart

Translated from French by Jeanine Herman.

Cover, top row, left to right: Bruce Nauman, Anthro/Socio (Rinde Facing Camera) [detail], 1991, six videodisc players, six color monitors, three video projectors, and six video discs, dimensions variable. Installation view. Daniel Martinz, Museum Tags: Second Movement (Overture) or Overture con Claque— Overture with Hired Audience Members (detail), 1993, metal visitor tags, 1¼  x 1" each. From the 1993 Whitney Biennial. Robert Gober, Untitled (detail), 199597, mixed media, dimensions variable. Matthew Barney, Cremaster 4 (detail), 1994, production still from a color video transferred to 35mm, 42 minutes 40 seconds. Photo: Peter Strietmann. Second row, left to right: Gabriel Orozco, Pinched Ball (Pelota ponchada) [detail], 1993, Cibachrome print, 9 x 13¼ ". Andreas Gursky, Chicago Mercantile Exchange (detail), 1997, color photograph, 70⅞ x 94½". Jeff Wall, A Sudden Gust of Wind (After Hokusai) [detail], 1993, Cibachrome transparency, aluminum display case, and fluorescent light, 90¼ x 12' 4½ ". Cindy Sherman, Untitled (detail), 1994, Cibachrome print, 44 x 30". Vanessa Beecrof, US Navy SEALs, 1999. Performance view, Museum of Contemporary Art, San Diego. Photo: Todd Eberle. Tableau vivant by Jack Smith (detail), ca. 1957/1997, uncropped color photograph printed from a 2¼ x 2¼" negative taken with a reflex camera. Francis Francine. The Plaster Foundation, New York. Third row, left to right: Elizabeth Peyton, Blur Kurt (detail), 1995, oil on Masonite, 14 x 11". Charles Ray, Puzzle Bottle (detail), 1995, painted wood in glass bottle, 13' x 4" diameter. Cady Noland, Untitled, 1989, scaffolding, beer, car parts, and basket. Installation view. Photo: Michael Olijnyck. Monique Prieto, AM Safety Zone (detail), 1999, acrylic on canvas, 72 x 96". Jeff Koons, Puppy (detail), 1992, live flowers, earth, wood, and shell, 39 x 16 x 21'. David Reed, #332 (detail), 199394, oil and alkyd on linen, 26 x 110". Bottom row, left to right: Mike Kelley, Dialogue #2 (Transparent White Glass/Transparent Black Glass) [detail], 1991, blanket, stuffed animals, and cassette player, 74 x 49 x 11". Seydou Keïta, untiled, ca. 1954, black-and-white photograph. Pipilotti Rist, Let me sip your ocean (detail), 1995–96, video installation. Sigmar Polke, Gärtner (Gardener) [detail], 1992, acrylic on synthetic fabric, 114¼ x 114¼". Todd Haynes, Velvet Goldmine, 1998, production still from a color film in 35mm, 127 minutes. Brian Slade (Jonathan Rhys Meyers). Photo: Peter Mountain. Robert Mapplethorpe, Self-Portrait (detail), 1978, black-and-white photograph. The Estate of Robert Mapplethorpe, New York.
Cover, top row, left to right: Bruce Nauman, Anthro/Socio (Rinde Facing Camera) [detail], 1991, six videodisc players, six color monitors, three video projectors, and six video discs, dimensions variable. Installation view. Daniel Martinz, Museum Tags: Second Movement (Overture) or Overture con Claque— Overture with Hired Audience Members (detail), 1993, metal visitor tags, 1¼ x 1" each. From the 1993 Whitney Biennial. Robert Gober, Untitled (detail), 199597, mixed media, dimensions variable. Matthew Barney, Cremaster 4 (detail), 1994, production still from a color video transferred to 35mm, 42 minutes 40 seconds. Photo: Peter Strietmann. Second row, left to right: Gabriel Orozco, Pinched Ball (Pelota ponchada) [detail], 1993, Cibachrome print, 9 x 13¼ ". Andreas Gursky, Chicago Mercantile Exchange (detail), 1997, color photograph, 70⅞ x 94½". Jeff Wall, A Sudden Gust of Wind (After Hokusai) [detail], 1993, Cibachrome transparency, aluminum display case, and fluorescent light, 90¼ x 12' 4½ ". Cindy Sherman, Untitled (detail), 1994, Cibachrome print, 44 x 30". Vanessa Beecrof, US Navy SEALs, 1999. Performance view, Museum of Contemporary Art, San Diego. Photo: Todd Eberle. Tableau vivant by Jack Smith (detail), ca. 1957/1997, uncropped color photograph printed from a 2¼ x 2¼" negative taken with a reflex camera. Francis Francine. The Plaster Foundation, New York. Third row, left to right: Elizabeth Peyton, Blur Kurt (detail), 1995, oil on Masonite, 14 x 11". Charles Ray, Puzzle Bottle (detail), 1995, painted wood in glass bottle, 13' x 4" diameter. Cady Noland, Untitled, 1989, scaffolding, beer, car parts, and basket. Installation view. Photo: Michael Olijnyck. Monique Prieto, AM Safety Zone (detail), 1999, acrylic on canvas, 72 x 96". Jeff Koons, Puppy (detail), 1992, live flowers, earth, wood, and shell, 39 x 16 x 21'. David Reed, #332 (detail), 199394, oil and alkyd on linen, 26 x 110". Bottom row, left to right: Mike Kelley, Dialogue #2 (Transparent White Glass/Transparent Black Glass) [detail], 1991, blanket, stuffed animals, and cassette player, 74 x 49 x 11". Seydou Keïta, untiled, ca. 1954, black-and-white photograph. Pipilotti Rist, Let me sip your ocean (detail), 1995–96, video installation. Sigmar Polke, Gärtner (Gardener) [detail], 1992, acrylic on synthetic fabric, 114¼ x 114¼". Todd Haynes, Velvet Goldmine, 1998, production still from a color film in 35mm, 127 minutes. Brian Slade (Jonathan Rhys Meyers). Photo: Peter Mountain. Robert Mapplethorpe, Self-Portrait (detail), 1978, black-and-white photograph. The Estate of Robert Mapplethorpe, New York.
December 1999
VOL. 38, NO. 4
PMC Logo
Artforum is a part of Penske Media Corporation. © 2023 Artforum Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.